This pie chart from Fair Isaac’s consumer site, MyFico is really pretty. It has great colors and and it’s really motivating to have great credit.
Trouble is, I do all of those things in the pie-chart, yet my score still doesn’t stand up to where it should be.
Lets see. I have a great payment history, I owe very little, I have a long credit history, I have hardly no new credit (not too much anyway) and I have a great mix of credit types, so why is my score lower than I believe it should be?
Because credit scoring is flawed!
Credit scores have become big business since they are so readily available to consumers now. But how many consumers out there are paying higher interest rates because their credit score is wrong? Millions of consumers have errors in their credit reports that directly affect their credit score but most of them don’t even know.
Fair Isaac, the company who generates the credit score has monopolized scoring for years, but now its in a tug of war with the credit bureaus who have released their own version of the credit score. Fair Isaac says this is causing more confusion because now the consumer doesn’t know whose score is accurate.
Truth is, none of them are accurate. Let’s take my credit for example. I have a mortgage, a car loan and about 7 credit cards. I’ve had credit for over 20 years and I’m never late on anything. My credit card balances are about 400.00 (total) and my accounts have been opened for 15+ years or so. Yet my Fair Isaac credit score, just last week was 769. I don’t think that’s fair considering 850 is best, and based on my years of open accounts, low balances in relation to limits, limited inquiries, and good secure loans like my mortgage and car, why am I only in the 700′s?
To top it off, just 60 days ago it was 786. How does it change so rapidly? And say I had one or two inquires because I am refinancing my mortgage, is it fair to drop my score 20 points because I used my credit? Credit scores are ruining peoples lives because they are paying higher interest rates and being penalized for simply using their credit- responsibly.
If I have a bunch of inquiries and or I’ve been late on any of my accounts, then drop my score 20 points, but simply because I had one inquiry, my score has suffered pretty harshly. Lenders don’t care if I tell them why. They simply look at the number. So what needs to happen? We need to go back to human beings processing our loans and giving us credit based on our credit reports not a score that is always wrong!
I know credit. I really know credit. I’ve been a credit expert for over 20 years and I know what it takes to make a credit report shine. If I have very few inquiries, a couple of secured loans like a car and a mortgage, pay my bills on time and keep next to no credit card debt, then I should be rewarded. If the highest score is 850 then why do we rarely, if ever, see it?
Years ago lenders regularly relied on the content of your credit to give you fair rates. With scoring becoming such a big deal in the last 10 years, lenders rarely look at your credit reports anymore. They simply glance at the number that Fair Isaac spits out and your rates are based on that. The credit industry is a mess and it’s going to take more than a few changes to fix it.
Another beef I have is credit repair. All the credit bureaus and Fair Isaac attack credit repair and spin it to scare consumers into not doing it. We wouldn’t need credit repair if our credit reports were accurate.
A few years ago I pulled my credit because I was refinancing my car. What I found was shocking to say the least. I had 7 address variations, three different social security numbers and incorrect employment information. When I contacted the credit bureaus I was told that the information was added because applications submitted by me through lenders had the varied information and it was transplanted to my credit reports.
I think I know my own social security number and address, so shouldn’t these errors have been quickly removed with just a phone call? I had to spend weeks sending dispute letters to remove all the inaccurate data. It wasn’t quick or easy and my errors were pretty harmless. I’ve seen clients with multiple collection accounts all from the same creditor. How is it fair to report one charged off debt four times?
Lobbyist’ spend millions warning consumers against credit repair, when in fact, it’s necessary because of the flawed credit industry. Sure there’s people who try and remove accurate negative information but that’s the bureaus job to investigate the claims and act accordingly.
If the credit bureaus are doing their job then why is the Federal Trade Commission flooded with complaints? Now, more than ever we need to fix the credit system and stop relying on credit scoring. With the housing crash and economy in the toilet, consumers are going to see lower credit scores more than ever before. Credit repair is going to skyrocket because people are desperate. The credit bureaus and the credit scoring system has created a mess and we’re left to clean it up — yet were told not to.
I’m not alone in my beliefs. Do a Google search on credit scores and you will come across hundreds of credit forums where consumers rant about their credit and rattle their brains trying to figure out how to improve it. Credit issues are among the most popular Internet searches besides porn! People are confused and overwhelmed and a lot of them are angry. They are frustrated at the system and simply don’t know what to do to leverage their credit, so they too can get good rates on loans.
I for one, am an advocate of credit repair, whether you pay someone or do it yourself. It’s necessary and it’s not going to go away. As long as there is a demand, there will be a supply. If the credit bureaus really wanted to reduce the number of investigation requests they receive, they’d clean up their act. Simply report more accurate information and use the credit score as a tool, not a deciding factor. Human beings are underrated. I think we can all look at a credit report and surmise if its good or bad. Give us some credit – literally!
If you’re up for some reading, MSNBC also has some great information on this topic.
About the author: Kristi Feathers is a credit expert and author of Credit and Collection Success Strategies. Article copyright N2Credit.com 2008.
Image credit. Fair Isaac is a registered trademark of Fair Isaac Co. All opinions expressed in this article are those of the author.